Academy›Special courses: eight courses for day-to-day selling›A-to-z Guarantee, chargebacks and seller feedback: deadlines, responses, removal
Special courses: eight courses for day-to-day sellingCustomer service & returns

A-to-z Guarantee, chargebacks and seller feedback: deadlines, responses, removal

Course lesson 3/3 ⏱ ~14 Min. 🏅 up to 205 points By Enes Kurt Updated November 2026 Check your listing free →
What you'll take away

An unhappy buyer has three ways to turn a problem into a defect on your account: an A-to-z Guarantee claim with Amazon, a chargeback with their bank and negative seller feedback. All three feed into the order defect rate, but they differ in who decides, which deadlines run and what you can still do. This lesson covers the rules as of November 2026 for amazon.de and Seller Central Europe and notes the US differences where they matter.

1

Three routes to a defect: what feeds the order defect rate

InstrumentWho decidesTypical triggersCounts as a defect when
A-to-z Guarantee claimAmazonNot received, not as described, return not authorized, refund not issuedAmazon decides against you, or you refund only after the claim was filed
ChargebackThe buyer's bankThe buyer disputes the payment with their card issuerIt's a service chargeback and the bank rules for the buyer
Seller feedback with 1 or 2 starsThe buyerUnhappiness with shipping, service or even the productIt stays up and is neither removed nor struck through

The limit is below 1% of orders in a rolling 60-day window. An order counts at most once, even if a claim and feedback come together. Account health shows the values for seller-fulfilled and FBA orders separately. Why the rate swings wildly with few orders and what a plan of action looks like is worked through in the account health lesson; this one is about the individual cases.

In plain terms

An A-to-z claim is an in-house procedure: Amazon is the referee and knows the rules. A chargeback goes before an outside court, the buyer's bank. Amazon acts as your lawyer there, but can only argue with the documents you supply. Seller feedback isn't a procedure at all but an opinion, and opinions can only be deleted within narrow limits.

2

A-to-z Guarantee: when buyers may file a claim

The A-to-z Guarantee protects buyers on orders from third-party sellers. A claim is possible in these cases:

  • Item not received: at the earliest three days after the latest estimated delivery date.
  • Item damaged, defective or materially different from the description, if a return wasn't authorized.
  • Return or refund stuck: return rejected, label invalid, refund not issued after the return arrived.

Rules for the buyer come on top: they must contact you first and give you 48 hours. They can file up to 90 days after the latest estimated delivery date. Anyone who has requested a chargeback from their bank is excluded from the guarantee; there's no using both routes at once.

On FBA orders, Amazon takes care of shipping, delivery and returns. Claims are rare there, and Amazon takes on cases caused by its own fulfillment. The real risk lies with seller fulfillment, for example when you ship orders yourself while your FBA stock is empty.

Since May 2024 the guarantee in Germany also covers property damage and personal injury caused by defective products. Amazon pays claims under €1,000 that demonstrably stem from a defective product at its own discretion and informs you; larger claims are reviewed by Amazon or an appointed service provider together with you. Above a sales threshold Amazon requires valid commercial liability insurance. With valid proof and compliant behavior, Amazon doesn't recover amounts under €1,000 from you.

Example

In October your FBA stock of the AURELO set runs out, and you ship 40 orders yourself from your logistics partner's warehouse. One parcel gets stuck with the carrier. The buyer writes on Monday at 10 a.m.: “Where is my order?” Until Wednesday at 10 a.m. you have 48 hours for a solution before they may file a claim. Send a replacement set on Monday afternoon or refund the €24.99, and the case is closed. Wait for the claim and refund only then, and it usually counts anyway. With 40 orders in the 60-day window, the seller-fulfilled column then shows 2.5%, from a single case.

3

Responding to a claim properly

  1. Read the notification: reason, order, deadline. Amazon's help pages state 72 hours to respond to a request for information; if you don't respond, Amazon decides for the buyer and debits your account. Plan for one day, not three.
  2. Gather the facts: tracking with proof of delivery to the order address, ship date, message history, photos before shipping, return status.
  3. Decide: refund or prove. A claim that is denied or withdrawn by the buyer doesn't count as a defect.
  4. Respond: factual, in chronological order, short, with evidence. No opinion about the buyer.
  5. Appeal: if the decision goes against you, Amazon's help pages give you 30 calendar days after the debit to appeal, which only makes sense with new evidence.
Claim reasonEvidence that countsWeak arguments
Not receivedProof of delivery to the order address, with signature for higher values; on-time handover to the carrier“The carrier says it was delivered” without proof
Not as described or defectiveListing as it stood, photos before shipping, a return offered in the message history“Other customers are happy”
Return not authorizedAuthorization with date, label or return address provided“The deadline had passed” without reference to the return terms
Refund not issuedRefund record with date, date the return arrived“The item came back damaged” without photos and without a justified partial refund

Seller fulfillment has a built-in protection: buy shipping labels through Amazon's Buy Shipping service and hand over on time, and Amazon covers not-received claims under certain conditions. In the US this also includes answering buyer messages within 48 hours. The exact conditions for your marketplace are in Seller Central. How to keep messages so they later work as evidence is covered in lesson 1.

Most common mistake

The response as a settling of scores with the buyer: “The customer is lying, the parcel was delivered, we have 4,000 happy customers.” Reviewers decide on evidence, not outrage. One sentence with the tracking number, the delivery date and a pointer to the solution offered in the message history weighs more than a page of anger.

4

Chargebacks: when the bank decides

With a chargeback, the buyer goes not to Amazon but to their card issuer. There are two kinds, and only one concerns you:

  • Fraud chargeback: the card was misused and the cardholder doesn't recognize the purchase. Amazon handles these; they don't count toward your order defect rate.
  • Service chargeback: the buyer acknowledges the purchase but reports a problem, such as “not received” or “not as described”. This one is yours, and if the bank rules for the buyer, it counts as a defect.

The process: you receive a notification by email and in Seller Central under chargeback claims. Amazon states seven calendar days from the date of the email; the deadline in your notification is what counts. You can refund or represent the case: ship date, shipping method, tracking, proof of delivery, communication with the buyer, product information. The buyer doesn't see your submission; an Amazon investigator reviews it and passes it on to the bank. If you don't respond, Amazon may refund the buyer on your behalf and debit your account. From the buyer's request at the bank to a final decision often takes 90 days or more.

Tip

For every seller-fulfilled order, file ship date, tracking number and proof of delivery so you can pull everything together in ten minutes. Seven days sound long until a weekend, a public holiday and a trade fair fall in between.

5

Seller feedback: how it's created and how it counts

Buyers can rate you as a seller with 1 to 5 stars for up to 90 days after the order. 4 and 5 stars count as positive, 3 as neutral, 1 and 2 as negative; only the negative ones count toward the order defect rate. What's mainly displayed is the share of positive ratings over the past twelve months. Further rules:

  • Buyers can change or remove their feedback themselves within 60 days.
  • Star-only ratings: since August 2025, according to US reports, buyers can also leave stars without text. For such ratings the usual removal request isn't available; reporting a policy violation remains.
  • Public reply: in Feedback Manager you can reply publicly to feedback that has text. The buyer can't respond to it, so write briefly, factually and with the solution, not with questions.

Seller feedback is often confused with the product review. The two have different audiences, different effects and different removal rules:

FeatureSeller feedbackProduct review
What is ratedYou as a merchant: shipping, packaging, serviceThe product
Where it appearsSeller profile, offer listingProduct page, stars in search results
EffectOrder defect rate (1 and 2 stars), account healthClick-through rate, conversion, ranking
Removable forObscenity, personal data, product-only criticism; FBA fulfillment criticism is struck throughPolicy violations, such as rating the shipping instead of the product
Contacting the buyerA message to resolve the problemWith Brand Registry, through the Customer Reviews tool

Everything about product reviews, from building reviews to handling criticism, is in the review management lesson.

6

When feedback can be removed

Amazon removes seller feedback only in narrow cases. You submit the request in Feedback Manager with the matching reason:

  • Obscene or abusive language.
  • Personal data such as your full name, email address or phone number.
  • Product-only criticism: the feedback describes only the product. As soon as it also criticizes your service, it stays.
  • Fulfillment criticism on FBA orders: if the criticism concerns Amazon's fulfillment, the feedback is struck through with a note that Amazon takes responsibility for the fulfillment. It then no longer counts. Amazon doesn't always catch these cases on its own, so request it.
  • On-time shipping via Buy Shipping: delivery criticism on orders you shipped on time with a label from Amazon's shipping service can also be struck through.

What isn't removed: criticism of your service, even if you think it's unfair. The only fix is to solve the problem. The safe line: resolve the case completely and don't ask for removal. Many buyers adjust their feedback on their own afterwards, and they have 60 days to do so.

Important

Never tie a refund, a replacement or a voucher to a change in feedback, and never push a buyer to remove feedback or withdraw a claim. Both count as manipulation and put the account at far greater risk than any single negative rating.

Example

Two 2-star ratings for your AURELO set, both from FBA orders. The first reads: “Grinds too coarse for me, and the parcel arrived two days late.” Neither is your performance as a merchant: the grind is product criticism, the delay concerns Amazon's fulfillment. You request the strike-through in Feedback Manager with reference to FBA fulfillment and stand a good chance. The second reads: “Seller never answered my question.” That concerns exactly your performance, so it stays. At around 600 orders in the 60-day window it costs you about 0.17 percentage points of defect rate, and the lesson belongs in your message check schedule.

Checklist: claims and feedback
  • Notifications about claims and chargebacks go to an inbox that is read daily.
  • Ship dates, tracking numbers and proofs of delivery filed for every seller-fulfilled order.
  • When problems arise, a solution offered within 48 hours, not only after the claim.
  • Responses factual, chronological and backed by evidence.
  • Feedback Manager checked weekly, removal or strike-through requested where it applies.
  • No refund or service tied to a change in feedback.
  • Labels bought through Amazon's shipping service for seller-fulfilled orders where it pays off.
7

Expert insight: refund or prove, and what's left after Amazon decides

Every case has two prices: the money and the metric. For the AURELO set the money is small, €24.99. The metric, though, is expensive when there are few orders in the window: with 40 seller-fulfilled orders in 60 days, one defect costs 2.5 percentage points; with 600 FBA orders, 0.17. That leads to a simple decision rule:

SituationEvidenceRecommendation
“Not received”, tracking without deliveryWeakReplace or refund immediately, before a claim comes
“Not received”, proof of delivery to the order addressStrongReply politely with the proof; document it in the claim
“Not as described”, listing unambiguousMediumEnable the return right away, refund on arrival
Service chargeback, proof of delivery availableStrongRepresent within the deadline with all evidence
Service chargeback without trackingWeakRefund

The core: refunding pays off before the claim, not after. A refund within the 48 hours after the buyer's first message costs the money but no defect. The same refund after the claim usually costs both. Proving only pays off when your evidence is strong, because a denied claim doesn't count.

What's left after a lost decision. In Germany, Amazon's A-to-z decision doesn't bind you legally. The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) ruled in 2020 (case VIII ZR 18/19) that the guarantee rests on an agreement between Amazon and the buyer. Once your account is debited, your claim to the purchase price against the buyer revives, and you can pursue it outside Amazon, for example through a court payment order. For a €24.99 product, effort and costs almost always exceed the amount. For high-priced items with clear proof of delivery, on the other hand, the route can pay off. The defect in your metric is unaffected; this is only about the money.

Important

Legal action is a formal procedure, not a threat in the messaging system. Don't announce it to the buyer through Amazon messages to apply pressure; that can be treated as harassment. If you want to pursue a claim, get legal advice and use the customer data only for exactly that purpose.

Continue reading for free

The first lessons of every track are open to everyone. From here on you just need a free account: no subscription, no costs.

Still ahead in this lesson:
  • 2A-to-z Guarantee: when buyers may file a claim
  • 3Responding to a claim properly
  • 4Chargebacks: when the bank decides
  • 5Seller feedback: how it's created and how it counts
  • 6When feedback can be removed
  • 7Expert insight: refund or prove, and what's left after Amazon decides
  • ✓Quiz: 6 questions with instant feedback
✎ Practice

Your turn: 2 exercises

Solve them to unlock the quiz. Up to 30 points each when you get it right first time without a hint.

1
Spot the mistakes

Find the weak spots in the A-to-z response

A buyer has filed an A-to-z claim “not received” on a seller-fulfilled AURELO spice grinder set. This is the draft of your response to Amazon. Click the parts that do harm or prove nothing.

Order 305-1123581-3213455, AURELO spice grinder set, seller-fulfilled. Handed to the carrier on October 6, one day after the order. Delivered on October 8 to the order address; tracking number and signed proof of delivery are attached. The buyer is quite obviously lying, the parcel arrived. We have over 4,000 happy customers and have never had problems. On October 10 we offered the buyer in the message system to resolve the case with the carrier. The message history and a photo of the packed parcel are enclosed. We have also told the buyer we will sue him if he does not withdraw the claim.

Tap every part that contains a mistake (3 in total).
2
Pick all that apply

Which feedback can be removed or struck through?

Feedback Manager shows six negative seller ratings for your AURELO set. For which of them is a request for removal or strike-through worthwhile? Select all that apply.

Check yourself

6 quick questions, one at a time, with instant feedback. With a free account your progress is saved.

A buyer hasn't received their order. When, at the earliest, may they file an A-to-z claim?
For non-delivery the buyer must wait three days past the latest estimated delivery date and contact you first. They can file up to 90 days after that date.
You refund only after the buyer has filed an A-to-z claim. What follows?
A refund after the claim usually no longer prevents the defect. If you're going to refund, do it within 48 hours of the buyer's first message.
Which chargeback does not count toward your order defect rate?
Amazon handles fraud chargebacks, and they don't count. Service chargebacks, where the buyer acknowledges the purchase and reports a problem, count if the bank rules for the buyer.
Who reads your submission on a service chargeback?
The buyer doesn't see your submission. An Amazon investigator reviews it and forwards it to the card issuer, who makes the final decision.
Which negative seller feedback can Amazon remove?
Product-only criticism doesn't belong in seller feedback and can be removed. Criticism of your service stays, even if you've replied publicly.
Amazon decided an A-to-z claim against you. What applies under the 2020 BGH ruling?
The guarantee binds only Amazon and the buyer. After the debit you can pursue the purchase price outside Amazon; it doesn't change the metric.

Frequently asked

How long does a buyer have to file an A-to-z Guarantee claim?

Up to 90 days after the latest estimated delivery date. For non-delivery, at the earliest three days after that date, and in every case they must first contact the seller and give them 48 hours to find a solution. Anyone who has requested a chargeback from their bank can no longer file an A-to-z claim.

Can I get negative seller feedback removed on Amazon?

Only in narrow cases: obscene language, personal data, or feedback that criticizes only the product. Criticism of Amazon's fulfillment on FBA orders is struck through and then doesn't count. You submit the request in Feedback Manager. Criticism of your service stays; the only fix is to solve the problem.

What's the difference between an A-to-z claim and a chargeback?

Amazon decides an A-to-z claim under its own guarantee rules. With a chargeback, the buyer goes to their bank and the card issuer decides; Amazon represents you there with your evidence. Both can count as defects, but Amazon handles fraud chargebacks over misused cards.

← Previous lessonUnderstanding and reducing returns: from return rate to the root cause in your listing Next lesson →Amazon product videos: 60 seconds that sell even on mute
Enes Kurt
Founder of Listimo

Everything in this academy comes from more than ten years of hands-on work with Amazon listings, the same playbook behind Listimo: the tool that finds what holds an Amazon listing back and fixes it.