Academy›Special courses: eight courses for day-to-day selling›Understanding and reducing returns: from return rate to the root cause in your listing
Special courses: eight courses for day-to-day sellingCustomer service & returns

Understanding and reducing returns: from return rate to the root cause in your listing

Course lesson 2/3 ⏱ ~15 Min. 🏅 up to 215 points By Enes Kurt Updated November 2026 Check your listing free →
What you'll take away

Returns are part of online retail, and some of them can't be avoided: taste, a change of mind, a gift that arrived twice. The rest is self-inflicted, and that's the part you can reduce. It usually starts before the purchase, when the listing creates an expectation the product doesn't meet. This lesson shows what a return costs, how to read the reasons, what happens to the goods and how to fix the causes. It reflects the state of November 2026 for amazon.de and Seller Central Europe.

1

What a return really costs you

With FBA, Amazon handles the whole return: it refunds the buyer and charges the amount back to you. That leaves you with a bill of four items:

  • Referral fee: Amazon gives it back but keeps a refund administration fee. In the US that's 20% of the referral fee, capped at $5; the current European rate is in the fee schedule in Seller Central. The math below also uses 20%.
  • FBA fulfillment fee: it isn't refunded.
  • The goods: if they come back sellable, they go back into stock. If they're damaged or defective, their value is lost, and returning them to you or disposing of them costs fees.
  • Returns processing fee when the return rate is unusually high, charged only on units above your category's threshold (next chapter).

How returns fit into your overall numbers is covered in the unit economics lesson; the other FBA fees are explained in the fee map.

Example

Your AURELO spice grinder set: €24.99 gross, €3.75 referral fee, €3.90 FBA fulfillment fee, €5.82 landed cost (€4.50 purchase plus freight and duty). If a return comes back sellable, you lose the €0.75 administration fee (20% of €3.75) and the €3.90 fulfillment fee, €4.65 in total. If the grinder is unsellable, add €5.82 of goods value: €10.47 before disposal. Assume 60% of returns come back sellable and 40% don't, and each return costs you about €6.98 on average. That's almost exactly your profit before ads per unit sold (€7.03): every return eats a whole sale.

2

Return rate by category and the fee threshold

How many returns are normal depends heavily on the category. Clothing and shoes sit far up because of size and fit; books and many household items sit far down. Good products outside fashion usually land at 2 to 5% in practice. Since 1 February 2025, Amazon has turned these differences into a fee question in Germany, France, Italy, Spain and the UK: for FBA products whose return rate exceeds their category threshold, a returns processing fee applies to each unit above the threshold. Some thresholds for amazon.de when the rule started:

CategoryThreshold at the 2025 startWhat it shows
Books3.57%Wrong purchases are rare, so the margin is small
Handmade3.70%One-offs rarely come back
Jewelry6.90%Looks and size drive more returns
Electronics14.67%Compatibility and usage are common reasons

The rules of the game: the rate is measured per product and month, namely the units shipped in one month against their returns in that month and the two following months. Products with fewer than 25 units shipped per month are exempt, and so are clothing and shoes, which have their own return fees. The current threshold table and fee amounts are in Seller Central. Amazon adjusts the thresholds: according to a trade source, in 2026 they were for example 21.43% for electronics and 12.86% for kitchen and home. Always work with the value in your account.

In plain terms

The threshold works like a tax-free allowance: up to the threshold you pay nothing extra, and above it every additional unit is charged. That's why going from 6.5 to 7% costs you fees if your threshold is 6%, while going from 4 to 5% doesn't. The returns themselves cost you in both cases, of course.

Example

Assume the threshold for your AURELO set's category is 6%. In March you ship 300 units, and by the end of May 21 of them have come back, which is 7%. Only units above the threshold are charged: 6% of 300 is 18, so the 3 above it are billed. Bring the rate down to 5% and the fee disappears entirely, and you also save 6 returns at about €6.98 each, close to €42 a month.

3

Reading return reasons: what buyers say and what they mean

Your most important source is the FBA customer returns report. For each return it lists the date, order ID, ASIN, the reason the buyer chose, the condition after Amazon's inspection and, if the buyer wrote something, their comment. Reasons appear as codes:

Code (selection)What's usually behind itYour lever
NOT_AS_DESCRIBEDImage, size, color or material differs from expectationsListing: images, bullets, dimensions
DEFECTIVE, QUALITY_UNACCEPTABLEA real defect or quality below the expected levelProduct, batch, supplier
MISSING_PARTSA part is missing or the contents were unclearPacking list, what's-in-the-box image
DAMAGED_BY_CARRIERTransit damagePackaging, padding
UNWANTED_ITEM, ORDERED_WRONG_ITEMChange of mind or wrong variant chosenVariant names, comparison image
NOT_COMPATIBLEDoesn't fit the buyer's device or accessoriesCompatibility information
SWITCHEROOWrong item deliveredCheck labeling and inventory assignment

Two rules for reading. First: buyers pick the reason themselves, and not always accurately. In practice, some “defective” returns are really wrong orders or a change of mind. Second: the comment is worth more than the code. “Much smaller than in the photo” under DEFECTIVE is a listing problem, not a quality problem. You know the method for analyzing customer text systematically from the niche validation lesson; here you apply it to your own product.

Most common mistake

Tracking only the rate and never reading the comments. A rate tells you something is wrong, but not what. Switch suppliers at a 6% return rate when half the comments say “smaller than expected” and you pay for a new supplier while keeping the old problem.

4

Voice of the Customer: NCX rate and customer experience health

The Voice of the Customer dashboard in the Performance area of Seller Central pulls the signals together per offer. Its building blocks:

  • NCX rate: the share of orders with a negative customer experience. It counts returns, refunds, complaints in messages, A-to-z claims and critical reviews. Each order counts once, even if the buyer used several channels.
  • CX Health: a rating from “Excellent” to “Very Poor”, set by comparison with similar offers. An NCX rate of 4% can be good in one category and poor in another.
  • Top return reason and customer comments: the shortcut to the cause without working through the returns report yourself.
  • Consequences: Amazon can close offers with conspicuous values; the dashboard shows the date of the last closure. Improvements only become visible after weeks, because the values are based on past orders.
Tip

Once a month, sort the dashboard by the number of NCX orders, not by NCX rate. A niche item with 2 out of 10 orders has a dramatic rate, but your bestseller with 18 out of 300 costs you more money. Work through the list from the top.

5

What happens to returned goods

Every return is inspected in the Amazon warehouse and assigned a condition. That decides whether the unit is sold again and who carries the loss:

Condition in the reportMeaningWho carries the loss
SELLABLEIn perfect condition, back into sellable stockNo loss of goods
CUSTOMER_DAMAGEDDamaged by the buyer or opened so it can no longer be sold as newYou
DEFECTIVEDefective or reported as defectiveYou
CARRIER_DAMAGEDDamaged in transitAmazon, under its reimbursement policy
DISTRIBUTOR_DAMAGEDDamaged in the warehouseAmazon, under its reimbursement policy
EXPIREDShelf life too short to sellYou

Unsellable units end up in unfulfillable inventory. From there you have three routes: have them returned to you (removal order), have them disposed of, or recover value where the program is available: through FBA Liquidations to bulk buyers or through FBA Grade and Resell as used goods in the condition Amazon assigns. Not every account and not every location is enabled for this; check what your account offers. Regularly have a sample of units graded unsellable sent back to you: if some of them are flawless, Amazon graded them wrongly and you check a reimbursement claim.

Important

If you haven't chosen an automated setting for unfulfillable inventory, it has been removed or donated after 23 days in the EU and UK since September 2024, and a disposal order can no longer be canceled after that. If you want to inspect returns, set up an automatic return to yourself in your settings.

6

Refunds on returns: who pays what

With FBA, Amazon decides on returns and refunds under its own return rules. You don't take part in that decision; you check afterwards:

  • The buyer gets their money, in practice often while the parcel is still on its way. You get the referral fee back minus the administration fee, but not the fulfillment fee.
  • If the goods don't arrive at the warehouse after a refund, you're entitled to a reimbursement from Amazon; the same goes for damage in the warehouse or in transit. How to find such cases and which deadlines apply is covered in the reimbursements and fee forensics lesson.
  • At 30 days in most categories, Amazon's return window is longer than the statutory 14-day right of withdrawal. Since 1 September 2026, according to trade media, 18 categories on amazon.de (including beauty, drugstore, pet supplies, furniture and mobile electronics) only allow 14 days plus 14 days to send the item back; your account shows which categories. In the holiday season Amazon regularly extends it: purchases from 1 November to 25 December 2026 can be returned until 31 January 2027, in exception categories such as electronics, toys and kitchen until 15 January 2027. December returns therefore sometimes only arrive in January.

With seller fulfillment, you handle return requests yourself but must offer at least Amazon's return terms:

  • Approve returns within the window and provide a return label or the return address. Leave requests sitting or reject them and you risk an A-to-z claim (see lesson 3).
  • Refund promptly. Under German law you must refund within 14 days of the withdrawal, but you may wait until the goods are back or the buyer proves they were sent. If the refund doesn't happen, that's also grounds for an A-to-z claim.
  • Partial refunds only with a reason: a deduction for loss of value is allowed when the item was used or damaged beyond normal inspection. Document it with photos.
7

Fixing the causes in your listing

Most avoidable returns happen before the purchase: the listing creates an expectation the product doesn't meet. So the remedies are almost always listing work, exactly at the spot the comment points to:

Comment patternCause in the listingAction
“Much smaller than expected”No size reference in the images, dimensions only in textSize image with a hand or everyday object, dimensions in the first bullet (image stack)
“Part missing”, “where's the stand?”Unclear contents, accessories shown but not includedA what's-in-the-box image showing only what's in the carton
“Can't adjust it”Operation is taken for grantedUsage image, quick guide as an insert, answer in the A+ content
“Ordered the wrong size”Variants hard to tell apartClear variant names, comparison image of the variants
“Cheaply made”Images and text oversell the materialName the material honestly (bullet points)

One principle applies: an honest limitation costs a few sales and saves many returns. “For pepper and coarse sea salt, not for damp salt” loses a few buyers who would have sent the product back anyway. Whether a change worked is measured with the method from the data-driven listing optimization lesson and with the mature cohorts from the next chapter. If the complaints point to the goods themselves, the topic belongs with your supplier (sourcing).

Example

Voice of the Customer shows an NCX rate of 6% for your AURELO set, top reason NOT_AS_DESCRIBED. Of 30 comments you read, 12 mention size (“smaller than expected”) and 7 the grind setting; the rest are scattered. You swap the third image for a size shot with a hand and a standard spice jar, put “18 cm tall, 5 cm diameter” at the start of the first bullet and add a card with three usage steps. The goal isn't zero returns, but the nearly two thirds of returns whose cause lies in the listing.

Checklist: returns under control
  • Return cost per unit calculated for every product, sellable and unsellable case.
  • Threshold for your own category looked up in Seller Central.
  • Returns report pulled monthly, at least 30 comments read per top product.
  • Voice of the Customer sorted by number of NCX orders and worked from the top.
  • Automated setting for unfulfillable inventory chosen.
  • Samples of units graded unsellable inspected yourself.
  • One listing change per cause, impact measured with mature cohorts.
8

Expert insight: calculating the return rate as a cohort

Returns arrive with a delay: some within the shipping month, some in the following month, a few later. That's why Amazon measures the fee rate over the shipping month plus two following months. If you instead divide a calendar month's returns by the same month's sales, or treat the latest month as final, you see systematically flattering values and draw the wrong conclusions from every change.

The fix is the cohort view: each shipping month is a group, and you assign every return to the month in which the unit was shipped. Your own history tells you what share of a cohort's eventual returns has arrived after how many months: its maturity. With it you project young cohorts forward. Assumption for the AURELO set: 55% of returns arrive in the shipping month, 85% by the end of the following month, 100% by the end of the month after that. Status at the end of October:

Shipping monthShippedReturns so farMaturityObservedProjected
August30016100%5.3%5.3%
September3001485%4.7%5.5%
October300955%3.0%5.5%

The apparent plunge to 3% in October is pure immaturity. If you swapped the size image in early October, this number proves nothing yet. December adds a second effect: with the extended holiday returns, the December cohort only matures at the end of January.

The second trap is chance. With 300 units and a true rate of 5.5%, the monthly value swings purely by chance within a 95% range of roughly 2.9 to 8.1%, about ±2.6 percentage points. A month at 4.5% is therefore no success and one at 6.5% no alarm. Only three mature months pooled (900 units) bring the blur down to about ±1.5 points. The mix of reasons reacts faster than the rate: if the share of “smaller than expected” among comments falls from 40 to 10% after the new image, that's a signal while the overall rate is still noisy. How to set control limits for metrics like this is covered in the KPI cockpit lesson.

Important

Compare before and after only with mature cohorts and enough units. Book a listing change as a success after four weeks and you're measuring the immaturity of the youngest cohort, not the effect of the change, and building your next decision on a number that is still moving.

Continue reading for free

The first lessons of every track are open to everyone. From here on you just need a free account: no subscription, no costs.

Still ahead in this lesson:
  • 2Return rate by category and the fee threshold
  • 3Reading return reasons: what buyers say and what they mean
  • 4Voice of the Customer: NCX rate and customer experience health
  • 5What happens to returned goods
  • 6Refunds on returns: who pays what
  • 7Fixing the causes in your listing
  • 8Expert insight: calculating the return rate as a cohort
  • ✓Quiz: 6 questions with instant feedback
✎ Practice

Your turn: 2 exercises

Solve them to unlock the quiz. Up to 30 points each when you get it right first time without a hint.

1
Calculation

What does an average return cost you?

Your AURELO spice grinder set (€24.99) is sold via FBA. Referral fee €3.75, of which Amazon keeps 20% as an administration fee on a refund. FBA fulfillment fee €3.90, landed cost €5.82.

According to your returns report, 70% of returns come back sellable and 30% are unsellable. Leave disposal costs aside.

What does one return cost you on average? Answer in euros, two decimal places.
2
Sort it

Where do you fix this return?

You are reading the comments in the returns report for your AURELO set. Match each return to the lever that fixes its cause.

“Much smaller than in the photo”, reason chosen: DEFECTIVE
“The picture showed a stand, but it wasn't in the box”
“Grinding mechanism broke after a week”, clustered in the same shipment
“Box crushed, glass body cracked”
“Instead of the spice grinders I got a completely different item”
“Ordered the wrong size, the variants look the same”
“Can't adjust it”
“On several grinders the thread is crooked”, all from one batch

Check yourself

6 quick questions, one at a time, with instant feedback. With a free account your progress is saved.

What do you lose on an FBA return even when the item comes back sellable?
The fulfillment fee isn't refunded, and Amazon keeps an administration fee from the referral fee. For the AURELO set that's €4.65 per return, even when the grinder is sold again.
How does Amazon measure the rate for the high-return-rate fee?
It's measured per shipping month: units shipped against their returns in the same and the two following months. Only units above the category threshold are charged.
Many returns carry the reason “not as described”. Where do you look first?
“Not as described” almost always means the expectation from images and text doesn't match the product. The comments show you where.
What does the NCX rate in Voice of the Customer show?
The NCX rate counts returns, refunds, complaints, A-to-z claims and critical reviews. The CX Health rating next to it compares the rate with similar offers.
A return comes back with the condition CUSTOMER_DAMAGED. What does that mean for you?
Goods damaged by the buyer are your loss. Amazon reimburses damage in the warehouse or in transit, not damage caused by the customer.
At the end of October the October cohort shows 3% returns and the August cohort 5.3%. What follows?
Returns arrive with a delay. A young cohort always looks too good; only mature cohorts or a projection with your own maturity curve allow a comparison.

Frequently asked

How much does a return cost on Amazon FBA?

You don't get the FBA fulfillment fee back, and Amazon keeps an administration fee from the refunded referral fee. If the goods come back unsellable, you also lose their value and pay for return shipping to you or disposal. If the return rate is unusually high, a returns processing fee is added for units above the category threshold.

What happens to returned items with Amazon FBA?

Amazon inspects every return and assigns a condition. Flawless goods go back into sellable stock; damaged or defective ones go into unfulfillable inventory. From there you have them returned, disposed of or, where available, liquidated or resold as used. Without an automated setting, in the EU they are removed or donated after 23 days.

At what return rate does Amazon charge an extra fee?

It depends on the category. Since February 2025, Germany, France, Italy, Spain and the UK have a threshold per category for FBA products, at the start for example 3.57% for books and 14.67% for electronics, in 2026 according to a trade source for example 21.43% for electronics. Amazon adjusts the thresholds. Only units above the threshold are charged; clothing, shoes and products with fewer than 25 units shipped per month are exempt.

← Previous lessonBuyer messages: reply fast, write compliant, protect your account Next lesson →A-to-z Guarantee, chargebacks and seller feedback: deadlines, responses, removal
Enes Kurt
Founder of Listimo

Everything in this academy comes from more than ten years of hands-on work with Amazon listings, the same playbook behind Listimo: the tool that finds what holds an Amazon listing back and fixes it.