Academyβ€ΊSpecial courses: eight courses for day-to-day sellingβ€ΊMeasuring profit per ASIN properly: contribution margin instead of gut feeling
Special courses: eight courses for day-to-day sellingNumbers & bookkeeping

Measuring profit per ASIN properly: contribution margin instead of gut feeling

Course lesson 3/3 ⏱ ~13 Min. πŸ… up to 215 points By Enes Kurt Updated November 2026 Check your listing free β†’
What you'll take away

Your account makes money, the monthly calculation shows that. But which product makes it? As soon as you run more than one ASIN, a strong bestseller can hide two weak products so well that you fund their losses for years. You know the per-unit plan from lesson 7 of the Getting started track, the monthly P&L from the KPI lesson and the return on capital per product from the product line lesson. This lesson closes the gap in between: it shows how you cleanly assign the costs Amazon does not deliver ready-made per product, in which order you deduct them and which decision follows from which level.

1

Why account profit tells you nothing about a single ASIN

Three distortions make it possible for a healthy account to contain sick products:

  • The bestseller carries everyone. If one product earns far more than the others, the total looks fine, even when individual ASINs contribute nothing.
  • Advertising runs at account level. If you only know total ad spend, you mentally spread it evenly. In reality a large share often flows into a small product that barely sells without ads.
  • Storage and returns disappear in the noise. Storage fees and return costs arrive as lump items. A bulky product that turns slowly, or one with a high return rate, never stands out that way.

The fix is not a new metric but a fixed order: you deduct costs per ASIN in levels, from the clearly assignable ones down to those you can only allocate. These levels are called contribution margins.

2

The contribution margin levels

LevelWhat is deductedQuestion it answers
CM INet revenue minus cost of goods (landed cost), referral fee, FBA fulfillment fee, packaging and EPR per unitDoes the product earn enough on a single sale at all?
CM IIminus advertising and promotions for this ASIN: sponsored ads, coupon and deal feesDoes the product carry the advertising it needs to sell?
CM IIIminus storage fees, return costs and product-specific fixed costs (such as certificates, tests)Is anything left after everything only this product causes?
Resultminus allocated overhead: account fee, software, tax advisor, insurance, your own timeWhat does the full-cost view look like?
In plain terms

Contribution margin means: how much does this product contribute to covering the costs that arise anyway? The account fee, your accountant and your software cost the same whether you run three products or four. Every product with a positive CM III puts something into that shared pot, even if on its own it looks negative β€œafter everything”.

Example

CM I per unit for the AURELO spice mill set: €21.00 net minus €5.82 landed cost (€4.50 purchase, €1.10 freight, €0.22 duty), minus €3.75 referral fee, minus €3.90 FBA fulfillment fee, minus €0.25 packaging and EPR = €7.28. The €7.03 profit before ads from the unit calculation is the same math, except that the €0.25 per unit share of storage space has already been deducted there. In the contribution margin calculation that item moves into CM III, because it does not depend on the individual sale but on how long and how much stock sits in the warehouse.

3

Assigning advertising costs to the right ASIN

Advertising is the largest item you have to assign yourself. Three rules cover almost every account:

  1. Assign Sponsored Products directly. The advertising report at advertised product level gives you the costs per ASIN. Nothing to estimate here.
  2. Allocate campaigns with several ASINs by sales. Sponsored Brands and Display often promote several products. Allocate campaign costs by the sales the campaign attributed to each ASIN. If there are none, allocate by clicks to the product pages or, if in doubt, evenly across the advertised ASINs, never across the whole account.
  3. Costs stay with the advertised ASIN. If someone clicks the ad for the mortar and buys the set, the revenue belongs to the set but the click costs belong to the mortar. Note this spillover effect separately instead of hiding it in the allocation. It matters for the decision, not for the calculation.

Coupon and deal fees also belong in CM II, because they are sales promotion for exactly one product. A good metric per ASIN is TACOS: the ASIN's ad spend divided by its total gross revenue. How the advertising stack attributes sales to campaigns is explained in the Pro lesson on advertising.

Most common mistake

Spreading total ad spend across all ASINs by revenue share. It looks tidy but hides exactly what you want to find: the product that eats a disproportionate share of the budget. Advertising is assigned by cause, not spread.

4

Assigning storage and return costs

Storage: the monthly storage fees report shows the fee per ASIN, calculated from the average volume occupied. On top come aged inventory surcharges for slow stock plus disposal and removal fees, which also arise per ASIN. Assign the storage fee to the month in which the goods were stored, even though Amazon only charges it in the following month. Otherwise the months jump around. Which fee types exist is shown in the fee map.

Returns: the return costs of an ASIN consist of three parts that no report shows as one number:

  • the refund administration fee: 20% of the referral fee, at most €5 per refund,
  • the outbound FBA fulfillment fee, which Amazon usually does not give back, plus return processing fees in some categories,
  • the cost of goods of units that come back unsellable, minus any reimbursement from Amazon.
Example

In March 18 AURELO sets are returned, 6 of them unsellable. The return costs: 18 Γ— €3.90 unrefunded FBA fulfillment fee = €70.20, plus 18 Γ— €0.75 refund administration fee = €13.50, plus 6 Γ— €5.82 lost cost of goods = €34.92. Together €118.62, so about €119. With 600 sales kept that is just under €0.20 per unit, a healthy value for a kitchen product. For a product with a 12% return rate the same math would look very different, and you find the causes with the returns lesson.

5

Overhead: allocate it, but don't decide by it

Overhead arises for the business as a whole: monthly seller fee, software, tax advisor, insurance, office and your own working time, if you count it honestly. For a full-cost view you allocate it with a key:

KeyWhen it fits
Share of net revenueDefault: simple, traceable, sufficient for most accounts
UnitsWhen effort arises per unit sold, for example with your own prep work
Time spentWhen individual products need a lot of customer service, upkeep or coordination
Volume occupiedFor the costs of your own warehouse outside FBA

Stick to one key and do not switch it from month to month, or you end up comparing keys instead of products. The full-cost view is good for two things: as a floor when pricing new products and as a reality check of whether the range as a whole carries your fixed-cost level.

Important

Never decide whether to delist a product based on the result after allocated overhead. Those costs do not disappear with the product, they just land on the others. Why that is so dangerous is worked through in the expert insight at the end of this lesson.

6

The monthly profit overview

Once a month, always on the same day and from the same sources, you build a table with one column per ASIN. For the AURELO range in March it looks like this (all values net):

MarchSpice mill setMortarRefill jars
Units sold (kept)600150300
Net revenue€12,600€3,780€3,276
CM I€4,368€1,095€1,056
Advertising and promotionsβˆ’ €1,200βˆ’ €600βˆ’ €820
CM II€3,168€495€236
Storageβˆ’ €150βˆ’ €180βˆ’ €40
Returnsβˆ’ €119βˆ’ €60βˆ’ €25
CM III€2,899€255€171
CM III per unit€4.83€1.70€0.57
TACOS8.0%13.3%21.0%
Overhead by revenue shareβˆ’ €897βˆ’ €269βˆ’ €234
Result after overhead€2,002βˆ’ €14βˆ’ €63

The assumptions behind it: the mortar sells for €29.99 gross, with €7.90 landed cost and a €5.20 FBA fee, CM I per unit €7.30. The refill jars sell for €12.99 gross, with €2.40 landed cost and a €2.90 FBA fee, CM I per unit €3.52. The account earns €1,925 in March after all costs.

Example

The table tells three different stories. The set carries the account: 87% of total CM III on 64% of revenue. For the mortar, advertising is within bounds, but storage costs of €180 on 150 sales point to an inventory problem, because the bulky product sits too long. For the refill jars, advertising eats 78% of CM I (€820 of €1,056), and a TACOS of 21% does not fit a product with €3.52 CM I per unit. Three products, three different levers, and none of them would have been visible in the account total.

Sources for the monthly overview
  • Units sold and refunded per ASIN from the date range report.
  • Landed cost per ASIN from your calculation, updated with every new purchase.
  • Ad spend per advertised product from the advertising console.
  • Coupon and deal fees from the service fees in the settlement.
  • Storage fees per ASIN from the monthly storage fees report.
  • Returns and condition per ASIN from the returns report.
  • Overhead from your bookkeeping, allocated with a fixed key.
7

Decisions: price, advertising, delisting

The level at which a product breaks down shows you the lever:

FindingLikely causeFirst lever
CM I per unit is thinPrice too low, purchase too expensive or unfavorable size tierTest the price, check packaging and dimensions, renegotiate
CM II is far below CM IAdvertising runs above break-evenAlign bids and targets with the break-even ACOS
CM III is far below CM IIStorage or returnsReduce stock, fix the return cause in the listing
CM III negative for three months in a row despite measuresThe product does not carry itselfPlan the sell-off, delist, redeploy capital

Price: for the refill jars a price test comes first. At €13.99 instead of €12.99 net revenue per unit rises to €11.76, the referral fee to €2.10, and CM I per unit grows from €3.52 to €4.21. Even if volume falls by 10% to 270 units, CM I rises from €1,056 to €1,136.70. How to measure the demand response instead of guessing it is shown in the lesson on price mechanics.

Advertising: advertising belongs where it generates CM II. If you cut advertising for the jars to €600 in the same step, CM II after the price increase rises from €236 to €536.70, provided volume holds at 270 units.

Delisting: only when CM III stays negative for three months although you have adjusted price, advertising and stock. Before that you check two things: is the product often bought together with a stronger one (the market basket analysis in Brand Analytics shows this for brand owners)? And what does exiting cost, meaning a discounted sell-off, removal or disposal of the remaining stock?

8

Expert insight: The overhead trap when delisting

Look at the last row of the monthly overview: mortar minus €14, refill jars minus €63. The obvious reaction is to delist both and carry on β€œwith the winner only”. Work out what happens then. The €1,400 of overhead keeps coming, because account fee, accountant and software do not shrink when two products are gone:

  • With all three products: €2,899 + €255 + €171 βˆ’ €1,400 = €1,925.
  • Without the refill jars: €2,899 + €255 βˆ’ €1,400 = €1,754, so €171 less.
  • With the set only: €2,899 βˆ’ €1,400 = €1,499, so €426 less.

And next month the set alone carries all of the overhead. If it then weakens, even the winner looks loss-making. This downward spiral only arises because allocated costs were treated as avoidable ones. The rule against it: only costs that disappear with the product are relevant to the decision. For the question β€œkeep or delist” CM III is what counts, not the result after overhead.

There are two exceptions where a positive CM III is still not enough. The first is capital: if a product ties up a lot of money in stock that would earn more in the bestseller, the return per euro tied up decides, as described in the product line lesson, provided the bestseller can actually sell the extra stock. The second is storage capacity. If Amazon limits your storage volume, the scarce factor is not money but space, and you rank by CM III per cubic meter:

MarchCM IIIAvg. volume occupiedCM III per mΒ³
Spice mill set€2,8992.0 mΒ³about €1,450
Refill jars€1710.3 m³€570
Mortar€2551.2 mΒ³about €213

The order flips: when space is tight, the mortar is scaled back first, not the jars, even though the mortar has the higher CM III. Make range decisions by a single column and you are often wrong. The right column depends on what is scarce right now: money, space or your time.

Continue reading for free

The first lessons of every track are open to everyone. From here on you just need a free account: no subscription, no costs.

Still ahead in this lesson:
  • 2The contribution margin levels
  • 3Assigning advertising costs to the right ASIN
  • 4Assigning storage and return costs
  • 5Overhead: allocate it, but don't decide by it
  • 6The monthly profit overview
  • 7Decisions: price, advertising, delisting
  • 8Expert insight: The overhead trap when delisting
  • βœ“Quiz: 6 questions with instant feedback
✎ Practice

Your turn: 2 exercises

Solve them to unlock the quiz. Up to 30 points each when you get it right first time without a hint.

1
Calculation

Work out CM II per unit for a new ASIN

A new AURELO salt mill sells for €19.99 gross at 19% VAT. Landed cost: €3.80. Referral fee: 15% of the gross price. FBA fulfillment fee: €3.40. Packaging and EPR: €0.20. Advertising and coupons: on average €1.50 per unit sold.

What is CM II per unit? Answer in euros with two decimal places.
2
Sort it

Which costs belong in which level?

Assign each cost item to the level at which you deduct it in the contribution margin calculation per ASIN.

Purchase price plus share of freight and duty
FBA fulfillment fee
Sponsored Products costs of the ASIN
Monthly storage fee of the ASIN
Unrefunded FBA fee on returns
Professional seller fee
Tax advisor's fee
Coupon fee for exactly this ASIN

Check yourself

6 quick questions, one at a time, with instant feedback. With a free account your progress is saved.

A Sponsored Brands campaign promotes three ASINs. What is the most sensible way to allocate its costs?
Costs follow their cause. Campaigns with several products are allocated by attributed sales per ASIN, never across the whole account, or the product that eats the budget disappears from view.
Someone clicks the ad for the mortar and buys the set. How does the ASIN calculation reflect this?
The click costs arise for the advertised ASIN, the revenue for the purchased one. You record the spillover effect separately and take it into account when deciding about the mortar.
Which item does NOT belong to an ASIN's return costs?
The monthly seller fee arises for the whole account, regardless of returns. It belongs to overhead, not to the CM III of a single ASIN.
An ASIN has a positive CM III but turns negative after allocated overhead. What follows?
Overhead does not disappear with the product. Drop an ASIN with a positive CM III and its contribution is missing, the fixed costs remain, and total profit falls.
Amazon limits your storage volume. By which metric do you rank your ASINs?
When space is the scarce factor, what counts is the contribution per unit of that factor. A small product with a lower CM III can earn more per cubic meter than a large one.
Where in the calculation does an ASIN's advertising problem show most clearly?
Between CM I and CM II there is nothing but this ASIN's advertising and promotions. If that step eats a large part of CM I, advertising runs above break-even.

Frequently asked

How often should I calculate profit per ASIN?

Once a month, always on the same day and from the same sources. For decisions also look at the average of the last three months, because storage fees, return waves and promotions distort individual months. Never delist because of a single weak month.

Is a spreadsheet enough, or do I need software?

Up to about 20 ASINs a well-built spreadsheet with one column per product and fixed sources per row is enough. What matters is not the tool but that landed cost, advertising, storage and returns are assigned per ASIN instead of estimated. With very many ASINs an automated evaluation of the reports pays off.

Do I calculate variations individually or as a family?

Individually as soon as price, purchase cost, size tier or return rate differ between variations, otherwise the strong variation hides the weak one. If they differ only in color and hardly in the numbers, the family is enough. Storage costs and returns, however, you always look at per child ASIN.

← Previous lessonBookkeeping for Amazon sellers: documents, booking logic, retention and your accountant Next lesson β†’Gear and lighting for product photos: the setup under €150
Enes Kurt
Founder of Listimo

Everything in this academy comes from more than ten years of hands-on work with Amazon listings, the same playbook behind Listimo: the tool that finds what holds an Amazon listing back and fixes it.